JERUSALEM (CNS) -- Protesting several recent
actions they described as a "systematic campaign ... against the churches
and the Christian community in the Holy Land," the heads of Christian
churches announced Feb. 25 they were closing of the doors of the Church of the
Holy Sepulcher for an undisclosed period of time.
Bewildered pilgrims milled around the square
in front of the church as Greek Orthodox Patriarch Theophilos III -- flanked by
Franciscan Father Francesco Patton, custos of the Holy Land, and Armenian
Patriarch Nourhan Manougian -- read a short statement to the press. At the same
time, the only two people allowed to close the doors -- the Muslim custodian of
the key, Adeeb Jawad Joudeh Al Husseini, and Muslim door keeper
Wajeeh Nuseibeh -- closed and locked the doors.
"This systematic and unprecedented
attack against Christians in the Holy Land severely violates the most basic ...
and sovereign rights, trampling on the delicate fabric of relations between the
Christian community and the authorities for decades," the heads of
churches said in their statement.
The church leaders were protesting the
Jerusalem municipality's intention to impose property taxes on church property,
such as hotels and convention centers, not used for worship purposes. The
proposal to levy taxes on some properties would run contrary to the unofficial
historical tax-exempt status the churches have enjoyed for centuries.
In addition, the church leaders said they
oppose a bill in the Israeli parliament that would limit the ability to sell
church-owned land to private owners. The bill, whose vote was postponed
following the church protest, would be specifically detrimental to the Greek
Orthodox Church, which owns large tracts of land in central Jerusalem upon
which many private homes are built; many of those 99-year-old building rental
contracts will soon expire. The church already has sold some of the land to
private owners, and homeowners whose apartments are on the land worry about
losing their homes.
Rachel Azaria, the member of Parliament who
sponsored the bill, said it is not meant to affect what the church can do with
its property, but what happens when the land rights are sold to a third party.
As media gathered to hear the church
leaders, pilgrims wandered around the church square, some kneeling in front of
the massive wooden doors -- the closest they would come to entering the church.
"We had one shot," said Flavia
Falcone, 25, an Italian Catholic living in Poland, who had come to Israel for
four days. "This was a bad decision. Faith and politics are two different
things. I came here all this way to see the church and I find it closed. It is
not very pleasant."
It is only the second time the doors to the
Church of the Holy Sepulcher have been closed in the middle of the day, other
than for traditional religious ceremonies. The other time was 20 years ago,
when a visitor to the church began taking down crosses and candles, said
The church leaders said taxing commercial
properties decreases revenues for the church's good works and breaches
"existing agreements and international obligations which guarantee the
rights and the privileges of the churches, in what seems as attempt to weaken
the Christian presence in Jerusalem."
"The greatest victims in this are those
impoverished families who will go without food and housing, as well as the
children who will be unable to attend school," they said.
In early February, the Jerusalem
municipality announced it would begin collecting $186.4 million in property
taxes from some 887 church-owned properties that were not houses of prayer.
Patriarch Theophilos has traveled to meet
world leaders, including Pope Francis, on the legislative issue.
Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat went on social
media in response to the Feb. 25 protest, clarifying that there was no
intention to tax places of worship, but rather church businesses such as hotels
and conference halls.
"Commercial buildings are not exempt
from municipal taxes regardless of their ownership," he said. He noted
that, by not taxing commercial properties owned by churches, Jerusalem
residents were missing out on revenue.
"We will no longer require Jerusalem's
residents to bear or subsidize this huge debt," he said in a tweet,
assuring that -- like all churches, synagogues and mosques -- the Church of the
Holy Sepulcher was exempt from municipal taxes.
In Amman, Jordan, Feb. 25, Mohammad
al-Momani, Jordanian minister of state for media affairs, called on "the
Israeli government to immediately reverse the decisions taken against churches
and respect its obligations under international law as an occupying power in
Under a 1994 peace accord with Israel,
Jordan is recognized as the legal custodian of Christian and Muslim holy sites
in Jerusalem. It is also only one of two Arab countries to have a signed peace
treaty with Israel.
In a statement made available to Catholic News Service, al-Momani reiterated "Jordan's absolute rejection
of Israeli authorities' systematic measures to change the historical and legal
status quo in East Jerusalem's holy sites, including Islamic and Christian
property and endowments as well as imposing further restrictions on Christian
churches in Jerusalem, the most recent of which was the Jerusalem municipality's
seizure of church property and bank accounts on the pretext of not paying
financial dues related to building taxes."
Meanwhile, the Advisory Council of the Catholic
Center for Studies and Media declared its categorical rejection of Israel's
moves, saying they are "incompatible with the historical position of the churches
in the Holy City and with their relations with the civil authorities.
It welcomed the Jordanian government's
forceful condemnation but also urged "the entire international community
to condemn the statement issued by "Municipality of Jerusalem" as
well as to pressure the government of Israel and the Municipality of Jerusalem
to revoke this decision."