“Looking on thee, O Unwedded One, and dreading a hidden wedlock, O Sinless One, the chaste Joseph was riven in mind with a storm of doubts...”
That is how the anxious state of Joseph was poetically described by the unknown author of the great Akathist hymn to the blessed Virgin Mary as he considered what to do with his young and pregnant betrothed. Joseph, following the usual Jewish practice, had been covenanted to Mary; their engagement was as legally binding as marriage. According to Jewish law, this meant the engagement could only end in one of two ways: divorce or death (see Dt 24:1-4).
Although devotion to St. Joseph has grown a great deal in recent centuries, it is still easy to overlook both the tremendous decisions he faced and the great character he demonstrated in making those decisions. Today’s reading from the Gospel of Matthew describes Joseph as a “righteous man.” This is not some vague reference to Joseph simply being a nice guy, but is a direct recognition of his wholehearted commitment to the Law. Joseph was careful to follow the commandments; he desired to love and serve God completely.
Yet he was faced with a scandalous situation: a young bride who was already pregnant. However, Joseph was “unwilling to expose Mary to shame” and had decided “to send her away quietly.” Some of the Church Fathers and doctors believed that Joseph had suspected Mary of adultery. Others thought he had withheld moral judgment, being genuinely perplexed by the strange situation. And some, including St. Thomas Aquinas, believed Joseph knew of the miraculous nature of Mary’s pregnancy from the start, and had sought to separate himself from her because of a sense of unworthiness.
We don’t know what Joseph knew before the angel of the Lord appearing to him. Rather remarkably, we also don’t know what Joseph may have said, simply because not one word that he uttered is recorded! But we do learn some important things from the words of the angel, as well as from Joseph’s actions.
The angel provided Joseph with three essential gifts. First, the divine messenger granted him the gift of peace: “Do not be afraid to take Mary your wife into your home.” The coming of the Lord is always a gift of peace to those who love and serve him. Second, he told Joseph there was a divine plan in place: Mary will give birth to Jesus — which means “Yahweh saves” — who will save his people from sin. Joseph would surely have recognized this as a description of the long-awaited Messiah. Finally, the angel provided the prophetic background to this stunning event, the passage from Isaiah. This would have further reinforced the reality of the divine plan.
Joseph, in turn, did three things. He thought, first and foremost, about Mary and her well-being. He acted justly, even though he had every legal right to be upset. Second, he placed his trust and hope in God’s promise. Although we never hear any words from Joseph, we are told of his actions. A godly man walks the talk, but with a minimum of talk! Third, Joseph embraced the daunting task of being the foster father of the Son of God. Why? Because he trusted in God despite the strangeness of the situation.
And what is the conclusion of the verse of the Akathist hymn quoted above? “But learning that your conception was of the Holy Spirit, he cried out: ‘Alleluia!’” Alleluia, indeed!
Carl E. Olson is the editor of IgnatiusInsight.com.